Showing posts with label fit and unfit for purpose. Show all posts
Showing posts with label fit and unfit for purpose. Show all posts

Wednesday, August 28, 2019

Criteria for Judging Public Officials, Leaders and Contenders: Character, Temperament, Intellectual and Experiential Qualifications, Credibility, Stability, Track Record, Quality of Stewardship (Policies, Actions, Relations)


Economic Conservative William Weld’s Critical Message Worthy of Attention

T

rump Demons contributing not to greatness but to Decline[Notes from contender Weld]

Trumpism, delusion, desire to be a king

Trumpism is … 
“a devotion to Mr. Trump’s megalomania [“a delusional mental disorder marked by feelings of personal omnipotence and grandeur”; “a mania for great or grandiose performance”].
“…He’s got a lot going on in his head. The man is so angry so much of the time it’s hard for me to see how one single head could contain so much anger; so much wrath.
“He is not a counter-puncher. He takes off with tweets or action after any slight, real or imagined.
“My read is the guy is terrified maybe he’s a loser, which is why he lashes out at anybody. I don’t know everything that’s going on there. But I do know that I would not want to have the president’s demons. I feel for the guy in a way. They’re not normal.
“When that sinks in, I think it’s possible that the president’s appeal could explode.
“[In Senior High School], I played Brutus in the Shakespeare play ‘Julius Caesar.’… So Cassius would come to me and say, ‘There was a Brutus once in Rome who would have brooked the eternal devil to keep his seat as easily as a king.’  That’s how Cassius got Brutus around to hold one of the 17 knives.
“I think about that all the time. We’re talking about a king here.
Donald Trump wants to be a king.” (emphasis added).
Foreign Policy and International Relations
“I take a holistic view towards international relations.
“I do not think the president does. He seems to want to insult our allies and cozy up to dictators … because he prefers an autocratic not to say tyrannical form of organization for government; and he sees himself at the top of that chain.
“Mr. Trump's foreign policy could not be more (of an) … anti-American-values and pro-tyrannical-dictator type regime.
“The country needs a foreign policy that doesn’t change with the president’s mood swings.”
C

onstitutional reality
“Having steeped myself … in the Federalist Papers and having studied the Constitution and the history of it, including the position of the anti-Federalists, I am pretty well aware of the extent to which the people who wrote our Constitution in Philadelphia in 1787 had one thought uppermost, with the one exception of Alexander Hamilton, and that would be: We don’t want a king (Emphasis added).
“I dare say that Mr. Trump has not read those debates.”
C

onservatism and Consequences of Trumpism
“I’m an economic conservative. And no one is doing anything about the jobs we’re going to lose with artificial intelligence and drones and robotics and self-driving vehicles.
“We’re just kind of whistling past the graveyard there.
“Those are Trump voters who are going to be displaced, the long-haul truckers who are not going to have a job when self-driving trucks come in.
“You could make it possible for displaced workers to get free instruction for technical skills for roughly 2 years, particularly if you beef up online curricula.”
C

arelessness of Trumpism
“…Doing nothing for the soon-to-be displaced workers who you would think are prototypical Trump voters. I’m sorry to sound so negative, but I don’t think he’s been really serious about policy.
“He’s been too busy flinging around phrases like ‘hoax’ and ‘wall.’ And not a lot of thought is going into what he says..”
C

are for Country and Constitution
The president takes an oath to uphold the Constitution. Among his duties specified in the Constitution is that he shall take care that the laws be faithfully executed.
“Mr. Nixon (37th U.S. President Richard M. Nixon, 1969–1974) violated that when he said to Haldeman and Ehrlichman, ‘We’ve got to stop this Watergate investigation. Tell them it’s national security, so they should just stand down.’”
“That’s failing to take care that the laws be faithfully executed.”
“…  With Mr. Trump you have dozens of things that amount to failing to take care that the laws be faithfully executed.
  • For example, in volume two of the Mueller report, the president is very clearly depicted as instructing senior national security officials, senior national intelligence officials and senior legal officials to lie. And they all say, ‘Well I can’t say that.’ And he says, ‘Why not?’ 
  • And they say, ‘Because that’s not true.’ 
  • And the president basically says, ‘Your point?’ 
  • And that’s just one in a litany of such examples.
W

eld in Brief
  • United States Attorney for the District of Massachusetts (1981–1986)
  • United States Assistant Attorney General for the Criminal Division (1986–1988)
  • 68th Governor of Massachusetts (January 3, 1991 – July 29, 1997)
  • Education: Harvard University (BA, JD); University College, Oxford
  • Campaigns: Pre-governorship U.S. Attorney for the District of Massachusetts, U.S. Assistant Attorney General for the Criminal Division; Governor of Massachusetts Governorship; Vice presidential campaign 2016 (Convention Election); Presidential campaign 2020 (Primaries)
  • Political party affiliations: before 2016 Republican; 2016–2018 Libertarian; 2019 -present Republican
William Floyd Weld (born July 31, 1945) is an American attorney, businessman, and Republican politician running for the Republican nomination for President of the United States in 2020.

T

hough the down side may be his brief change of political party, a former chair of the Massachusetts Republican Party and Trump critic, Jennifer Nassour, tells the press,
“It would be wonderful to have a moderate Republican running against Trump to give other voters in a Republican primary someone to vote for.”
Another possible down side that seems, on first glance, to side with Trump was reported in New Hampshire Public Radio. Weld reportedly
“…Flaunted the personal connections” with Israel’s prime minister when asked “his position on Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu’s plan to annex the West Bank.”
Said Weld
“‘I’ve known Bibi for a long time (since he was married to Fern). I used to go bar hopping with him and Danny Meridor when they were in their 20s.’”
Further
In April of this year, “Dan Meridor — who held several ministerial posts under Benjamin Netanyahu during his 21 years as a lawmaker between 1984 and 2013 — joined former Likud ministers Benny Begin and Limor Livnat in coming out publicly against the premier’s push to curb the authority of the High Court of Justice, and in the process, safeguard himself (with) immunity from prosecution in the three graft cases against him. [Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu is facing charges of fraud and breach of trust in three cases, and bribery in one of them.]
Meridor’s further reaction reported in the Times of Israel:
 “The idea that someone is above the law, that there is no equality before the law, that suspicions against the prime minister and ministers won’t be investigated and reach the court, is turning our country into something else. …
“We have had prime ministers and ministers, even a president, who went to jail. …
“The idea of an override clause — that we won’t be a democracy, that there will be a dictatorship and the majority can do whatever it wants, that the court can’t say anything and there are no checks and balances — is a dangerous anti-democratic idea. There is not a single parliament in the world without checks and balances.”
W

hatever Americans think or feel about one contender or another, for the sake of the people and the country (and other countries and peoples),
they (we) must begin taking into consideration more than their “feelings” and/or the superficialities and the basic birth-residence-age criteria concerning public officials and contenders for public office.
The notion that any and all Americans can “grow up and become president” (merely by growing up!) is not only outdated; it is ridiculous, foolish, absurd. It is also dangerous.

The world we live in is far more complex and the preparation, the performance examples and images, the educational and economic systems cultivating leaders, the seriousness of would-be democratic processes are sadly lacking —  far inferior to earlier times of the founding public servants and leaders.
 

This means Americans must 
  • look closely, studiously, critically, analytically; 
  • recover from the  beauty pageant-horse race-casino-win-lose-can't-can mentality; and 
  • actually do some homework 
  • use independent thought and 
  • apply substantive criteria in judging, deciding who will hold public office and who will care for and lead the country in moral character and able stewardship, in well-thought-out and respectfully negotiated policies and practices domestic and global.
  
Sources

Commonwealth Magazine “Weld rejoins Republican ranks” by Michael Jonas February 4, 2019   https://commonwealthmagazine.org/politics/weld-rejoins-the-republican-ranks/

New Hampshire Public Radio “2020 Candidate Conversation: Former Mass. Gov. Bill Weld” by The Exchange April 26, 2019 https://www.nhpr.org/post/2020-candidate-conversation-former-mass-gov-bill-weld#stream/0
NHPR “In N.H., This Time As A Candidate, Weld Rails Against Trump On Foreign Policy” by Lauren Chooljian April 17, 2019 https://www.nhpr.org/post/nh-time-candidate-weld-rails-against-trump-foreign-policy

William Weld https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bill_Weld

Merriam-Webster Megalomania

The Times of Israel  “Former justice minister for Likud warns of Netanyahu ‘dictatorship’”: “Dan Meridor blasts plan that seeks to curb the court’s power and ensure PM’s immunity from prosecution, saying it would ‘bulldoze’ the legal system and erode democracy” by Michael Bachner and TOI staff May 23, 2019 https://www.timesofisrael.com/former-justice-minister-for-likud-warns-of-netanyahu-dictatorship/


Insight Beyond Today’s News, CLB - © All Rights Reserved




Saturday, June 22, 2019

Americans Carelessly Discount Substantive Candidacy Prerequisites for Holding Public Office


Voters Prefer Personality over Character, Pageantry over demonstrated Qualification

As U.S. leaders persist in promulgating a delusion of U.S. “exceptionalism”; and, in their outbursts, persist in disparaging leaders and processes of other countries, it seems an appropriate time to look at Iran’s and the USA’s current heads of state and each country’s basic requirements for the presidency.  

I
slamic Republic of Iran (Persia)

Current President: Hassan Rouhani
Qualifications
  • Hassan Rouhani: politician, lawyer, academic, former diplomat and Islamic cleric; seventh President of the Islamic Republic of Iran (August 3, 2013 - )
  • First elected to the Majlis, the Parliament of Iran (1980, serving 20 years, 1980-2000, in positions including deputy speaker, head of defense committee, foreign policy committee); 
  • Deputy speaker of the fourth and fifth terms of the Parliament of Iran (Majlis) and Secretary of the Supreme National Security Council [1989- 2005, during which he served as his country’s top negotiator with the EU three (UK, France, and Germany) on nuclear technology in Iran]; 
  • Member of the Supreme National Security Council (1989- )
  • Member of the Supreme National Security Council (1989 - ); member of Iran’s Assembly of Experts (1999 - )
  • Dr. Rouhani also retains academic activities: member of the board of trustees of Tehran Universities and North Region (1995-1999); director of Center for Strategic Research (1991- ); managing editor of three academic and research quarterlies in Persian and English: Rahbord (Strategy), Foreign Relations, and the Iranian Review of Foreign Affairs.
Dr. Rouhani’s Education
  • Ph.D. Constitutional Law, Glasgow Caledonian University, UK (Thesis ‘The Flexibility of Shariah; Islamic Law’)
  • M. Phil. Law, Glasgow Caledonian University, UK (Thesis: ‘The Islamic legislative power’)
  • B. A. Judicial Law, University of Tehran
To his credit about 100 books and scientific papers; in 20 years, supervision of “development and writing of more than 700 important strategic studies, with policy recommendations”

Sample of Rouhani’s books  
  • National Security and Nuclear Diplomacy (October 2011)
  • National Security and Economic System of Iran (August 2010)
  • Islamic Political Thought; Vol. 1: Conceptual Framework (December 2009)
  • Islamic Political Thought; Vol. 2: Foreign Policy (December 2009)
  • Islamic Political Thought; Vol. 3: Cultural and Social Issues – December 2009
  • Memoirs of Dr. Hassan Rouhani; Vol. 1: The Islamic Revolution (2008)
  • An Introduction to the History of Shia’ Imams (2012)
  • Age of Legal Capacity and Responsibility (October 2012)
  • Introduction to Islamic Countries (2008)
The President of Iran is elected for a four-year term in a national election by universal adult suffrage for people who are at least 18 years old.

U
nited States of America 
Current President: Donald John Trump 
        Qualifications
  • The 45th and current president of the United States has no prior experience, training or education in government or public service
  • Donald Trump entered the U.S. presidency and prior candidacy with experience as a businessman and television personality.
Political party affiliations registered:
  • 1987 Republican Party (in Manhattan, NY) 
  • [Rumors of a Trump run for the U.S. presidency (though objectively unqualified) in 1988 prompted “then U.S. Senator John Kerry (Democrat from Massachusetts), House Speaker Jim Wright of Texas, and Arkansas Congressman Beryl Anthony Jr. (to invite) Trump to host a fundraising dinner for Democratic Congressional candidates and to switch parties.”]
  • 1999 Reform Party
  • 2001 Democratic Party
  • 2009- Republican Party
  • Partisan Political donor through 2010: U.S. Democratic and Republican parties, party committees, and candidates. 
  • Rated #10 “most admired man in America.” (Gallup poll 1988) yet by any objective measure unqualified for any public office position or head of state.
The President of the United States is elected for a four-year term with a possible reelection to no more than a second four-year term (22nd Amendment).

S
tandards and Process for the Presidency 
Iran 
The Constitution of the Islamic Republic of Iran mandates these qualifications to run for the presidency:
  • Iranian origin
  • Iranian nationality
  • Administrative capacity and resourcefulness
  • Good past record
  • Trustworthiness and piety
  • Convinced belief in the fundamental principles of the Islamic Republic of Iran and the official madhhab (Madhhab: “‘way of act’” or manner of being, “a school of thought within Islamic jurisprudence) of the country.
Disqualifiers
  • Within these guidelines — candidates deemed unacceptable are vetoed by the Council of Guardians, a twelve-member body consisting of six clerics (selected by Iran’s Supreme Leader) and six lawyers (proposed by the Supreme Leader-appointed head of Iran’s judicial system, and voted in by the Parliament).
  • “The approval process is considered to be a check on the president’s power, and usually amounts to a small number of candidates being approved. The procedures for presidential election and all other elections in Iran are outlined by the Supreme Leader.”

S
tandards and Process for the Presidency
United States of America
The Constitution of the United States of America (Article II, Section 1, Clause 5) mandates these (almost-nonexistent) qualifications to run for and hold the office of president:
  • Natural-born U.S. citizenship
  • At least thirty-five years of age
  • Residency in the United States for at least fourteen years.
Disqualifiers
  • The U.S. Senate has the option of disqualifying individuals convicted in impeachment cases from holding federal office in the future (Article I, Section 3, Clause 7)
  • Subject to reversal by a two-thirds vote of each house of Congress (Section 3 of the 14th Amendment), a candidate may be disqualified for the U.S. presidency if he/she “swore an oath to support the Constitution and later rebelled against the United States.”
  • No one may be elected to the U.S. presidency “more than twice (or once, if the person serves as president or acting president for more than two years of a presidential term to which someone else was originally elected)” (22nd Amendment)
C
urrent Events: United States - Iran Relations
“Iran has been loyal to its international commitments and agreements, and it was the other side that violated all agreements and regulations. Right now, everyone in the world considers the US administration as a government that violates its commitments and promises”— President Hassan Rouhani speaking at the opening ceremony of Salam Terminal-Gallery of Imam Khomeini Airport City:
“Despite all hardships and pressures that the enemies have imposed on us with the aim of convincing our people that the country’s development has stopped and the people are hopeless about the future, we are witnessing new developments in the economy of the country every day…. The people of Iran will disappoint the enemies by being hopeful and fervent, preventing them from reaching their goals.” June 18, 2019 http://www.president.ir/en/110155
 U.S. President
Though looking “forward to the day when ‘sanctions come off Iran, and they become a productive and prosperous nation again …
“We are putting major additional Sanctions on.’”— U.S. President Donald Trump on social media, reported in the press June 22, 2019

Sources

Iran, Hassan Rouhani https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hassan_Rouhani#Political_career_during_the_1980s_and_1990s
Dr. Hassan Rouhani, Honorable President of the Islamic Republic of Iran http://www.president.ir/en/president/biography
Madhhab https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Madhhab
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/President_of_Iran#Qualifications_and_election
USA, Donald Trump
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Donald_Trump
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/President_of_the_United_States
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_Two_of_the_United_States_Constitution#Clause_5:_Qualifications_for_office
Clause 5: Qualifications for office: Section 1 of Article Two of the United States Constitution sets forth the eligibility requirements for serving as president of the United States: No Person except a natural born Citizen, or a Citizen of the United States, at the time of the Adoption of this Constitution, shall be eligible to the Office of President; neither shall any person be eligible to that Office who shall not have attained to the Age of thirty five Years, and been fourteen Years a Resident within the United States.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Article_Two_of_the_United_States_Constitution#Clause_5:_Qualifications_for_office
President while opening IKAC’s Salam Terminal-Gallery: “Enemies’ war with Iranians based on war of hope, willpower/ Iranian nation to win the war of willpower/ Developing tourism a key goal of gov’t/ Appreciating all people at work in air industry” June 18, 2019  http://www.president.ir/en/110155

RT “Trump says ‘major additional sanctions’ on Iran to come Monday” June 22, 2019
https://www.rt.com/news/462470-trump-iran-additional-sanctions/


 
Insight Beyond Today’s News, CLB - © All Rights Reserved



Long Way from Madison—Time to Rethink, Revise

Qualifications Standards Enforcement  Prerequisites for Public Office We are a long way—carelessly and arrogantly distanced— from Madison, ...